If a new spate of 2018 election polls is anywhere close to accurate, Republicans have a serious problem in the Midwest.
NBC News and Marist released new surveys from Wisconsin, Minnesota, and Michigan on Thursday. They found Democrats leading by double digits in every Senate and governor’s race in those states. If true, Democrats can feel secure that they will retain three crucial Senate seats — including two in states Donald Trump won in 2016 — while also retaking two governor’s mansions currently held by Republicans in the 2018 midterms.
The key words there are “if true.” The Midwest was supposed to be Hillary Clinton’s “blue wall” in 2016, and polling showed her ahead; then Trump won several shocking victories on his way to the White House. So we have some reason to wonder about polling from the Midwest.
But first, the results:
Wisconsin governor: NBC/Marist found state school Superintendent Tony Evers running well ahead in a crowded Democratic primary, with 25 percent of the vote.
And in a head-to-head matchup with Republican Gov. Scott Walker, Evers had a huge 13-point lead: 54 percent to Walker’s 41 percent.
Wisconsin Senate: Democratic Sen. Tammy Baldwin led both of her possible GOP challengers by healthy margins:
- Baldwin, 55 percent; veteran and former Democrat Kevin Nicholson, 39 percent
- Baldwin, 55 percent; state Sen. Leah Vukmir 38 percent
In the GOP primary, to be held on August 14, Nicholson led Vukmir 38 percent to 35 percent among likely voters.
Michigan Senate: Democratic Sen. Debbie Stabenow has looked like a good bet for reelection for a while, and NBC/Marist reinforces that. She leads both of her potential GOP opponents by huge margins:
- Stabenow, 55 percent; African-American business executive and veteran John James, 37 percent
- Stabenow, 52 percent, business executive Sandy Pensler, 37 percent
The Republican primary will be August 7. The new survey found James leading Pensler 30 percent to 23 percent.
Michigan governor: Republican Gov. Rick Snyder is retiring with dismal approval ratings after the Flint water crisis.
Both parties still need to get through their August primaries, but NBC/Marist polled a hypothetical general election matchup with the leading candidates. They found Democrat Gretchen Whitmer leading Republican Bill Schuette 47 percent to 38 percent.
Neither looked like a sure bet for the nomination, though. Whitmer (35 percent) narrowly led fellow Democrats Shri Thanedar (25 percent) and Abdul El-Sayed (22 percent) among likely voters. On the other side, Schuette (36 percent) had a similar lead over Brian Calley (26 percent) with lots of voters undecided.
Minnesota governor: Republican former Gov. Tim Pawlenty is trying to regain his old office, with Democratic Gov. Mark Dayton term-limited, but NBC/Marist finds him in trouble. He trails all three of the top Democratic contenders:
- Pawlenty, 40 percent; Democratic US Rep. Tim Walz, 51 percent
- Pawlenty, 40 percent; Democratic attorney general Lori Swanson, 51 percent
- Pawlenty, 40 percent; Democratic state Rep. Erin Murphy, 48 percent
The Democratic governor primary, to be held August 14, is a free-for-all: NBC/Marist has Swanson at 28 percent, Walz at 27 percent, and Murphy at 13 percent among likely voters.
Minnesota Senate: Democratic Sen. Tina Smith is still a fresh face after she was appointed to the Senate last year to replace Al Franken. But she looks to be in a secure position to win her seat outright. Smith leads Republican Karin Housley 49 percent to 35 percent, per this new survey.
Why some smart people are a little skeptical of Midwest polling
You might remember that Hillary Clinton was leading Donald Trump in Michigan and Wisconsin, according to the polling, before Trump’s stunning victories in those states on Election Day 2016. Minnesota also ended up much closer than expected.
That has some polling nerds feeling reflexively skeptical of any strong Democratic numbers in the region. The New York Times’s Nate Cohn concisely laid out the reasons to take Midwest surveys with a grain of salt and provided some good guidance for analyzing 2018 polls, especially in any important Midwestern races.
Some of the NBC/Marist polls look like outliers: Marquette University found Walker leading Evers in Wisconsin by 4 points in June. These were also the biggest leads for Baldwin in her Senate bid, though she certainly seems to have the advantage, and election forecasters think she is increasingly safe.
On the other hand, the NBC/Marist findings were perfectly in line with previous polls for Michigan governor and Senate. For the Minnesota races, this is really the first polling we’ve seen.
The point is, be wary of taking these huge Democratic leads too literally. Still, the trend lines seem to be clear: Democrats are in good shape to compete — and maybe sweep — in the marquee Midwestern elections this year.